Isolating shutter via Relay

[Joe Doherty]

Got a customer who has a electric shutter operated via rocker switch concerned if intruder gets in through roof as easy access. They can just open up from inside, could I isolate the inside switch through a relay on the Intruder Set Output, Where do you stand on trapping "intruder" inside seems a very grey area ? 

[james.wilson]

id provide a relay for set status then let the shutter people wire it in

[MrHappy]

A key switch for the shutter is £15...

[Joe Doherty]

Keyswitch on outside, switch on inside it's rented so they don't want to start altering much.

[al-yeti]

3 hours ago, Joe Doherty said:

Got a customer who has a electric shutter operated via rocker switch concerned if intruder gets in through roof as easy access. They can just open up from inside, could I isolate the inside switch through a relay on the Intruder Set Output, Where do you stand on trapping "intruder" inside seems a very grey area ? 

Better detection near roof and master blaster

[james.wilson]

3 hours ago, Joe Doherty said:

Keyswitch on outside, switch on inside it's rented so they don't want to start altering much.

so don't then would be my take

[Simlec]

14 hours ago, Joe Doherty said:

Got a customer who has a electric shutter operated via rocker switch concerned if intruder gets in through roof as easy access. They can just open up from inside, could I isolate the inside switch through a relay on the Intruder Set Output, Where do you stand on trapping "intruder" inside seems a very grey area ? 

Has the roller shutter not got manual chain override?

I cant see a problem with disabling the electrical side of the shutter, give the Police more time to get there.

We have a unit that was done over last year and the insurance company have requested a padlock from floor to shutter and the manual chain to stop the scumbags opening it.

[SouthernBrad]

We used to do this on a National companies stores main entrance shutter.

When system was set the shutter controls didn't work.

System was Armed & Disarmed external via Max reader.

[datadiffusion]

On 14/07/2017 at 21:49, Joe Doherty said:

Where do you stand on trapping "intruder" inside seems a very grey area ? 

 

Intruder has gained access by circumventing a locked door - so if door remains locked, nil problemo.

 

I agree that it could be a grey area if, say, intruder was able to walk into somewhere without the use of tools or equipment then not be able to leave, i.e an open gate into a car sales forecourt that then locked itself.

 

That said it never seemed to be an issue with those pushbutton-to-exit-if-you-haven't-got-a-shotgun bank lobbies that seemed popular circa 2000 but now are usually swept away at refurb time. Nationwide seemed to use them a lot?

[al-yeti]

43 minutes ago, datadiffusion said:

 

Intruder has gained access by circumventing a locked door - so if door remains locked, nil problemo.

 

I agree that it could be a grey area if, say, intruder was able to walk into somewhere without the use of tools or equipment then not be able to leave, i.e an open gate into a car sales forecourt that then locked itself.

 

That said it never seemed to be an issue with those pushbutton-to-exit-if-you-haven't-got-a-shotgun bank lobbies that seemed popular circa 2000 but now are usually swept away at refurb time. Nationwide seemed to use them a lot?

Glow in the dark exit, voice box warning of imminent gas release (really a smoke cloak) 

 

He will run fot it , cage otherside