Guest chiquetete Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 Hi all, i found this forum looking for information about how the PIRs work. We are trying to develop a small project with wireless sensors and a computer. We would like to be able to "talk" with PIR sensors (we have one from Honeywell - 5888H) with a board that has a 868mhz transmitter, but we don't find any information about the protocol used by PIRs. Could someone help us? or do you where we could find this information (if it is public)? Thanks in advanced, regards. Juanjo.
Guest Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 So you would like us to give you the protocol on the public internet so anyone can hack into a wireless system, is that what your asking? Sorry I may have misunderstood you, Im not being sarcastic - Im curious now???
Guest chiquetete Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 Sorry, i think my post is going to create a great controversy... Let me explain we are doing a 'research' project for the University and change my question please. I should began asking if it is possible to obtain this protocol, is it public? I suppose it is not... I am sorry the way i did my previous questions... Regards.
Guest Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 I am sorry if it came accross the wrong way, but Im not happy about this advice being given sorry? maybe see what the other members think too. Dont appologise, you only asked a question after all
amateurandy Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 It isn't necessarily that silly a question, especially if you compare it to computer networks. The protocols used by wireless computer networks are (generally) public information, as are those for the internet. That's how they manage to work interchangeably (interesting debate there ). Security, as plenty of members on here will know, is achieved by using appropriate authentication and encryption. Also, there's a sort of "given" in the security world that "security by obscurity" doesn't work on its own. Your security mechanisms need to be robust and not just depend on being unpublished or obscure. So, maybe wireless PIR's do, or could, use publicly-published protocols. It would probably keep the costs down.
ian.cant Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 I would suggest you speak to the makers of the PIR's your using, they're the ones who are more likely to help you with this one.
Guest chiquetete Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 hi again, i don't anything about the protocol, that's why i was trying to find information. DNS Security, you have reason and my question is quite stupid, that's clear, and your reply is a good reply for my stupid post. I thought that the protocol would have a set of security mechanisms (that's what amateurandy says)... I will do what ian.cant says, and try to talk to the manufacturer, but i am sure i won't find a different replay, will i? I am affraid that the protocols are not public, so i won't obtain any information. when i came here to ask i thought that there should be some kind of organization or association of manufacturers of security wireless sensors, because some of them can interact. or am i wrong? regards,
Guest Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 DNS Security, you have reason and my question is quite stupid, that's clear, and your reply is a good reply for my stupid post. 61385[/snapback] No-one is calling you stupid You have a question, and that isnt stupid
Guest chiquetete Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 No-one is calling you stupid 61387[/snapback] Sure! DNS Security, do you think we are trying to do (my project) something impossible? i mean because we won't be able to find the protocol/way to talk to a PIR? Thanks to all for your help, regards.
Guest Posted July 19, 2005 Posted July 19, 2005 Its possible I suppose - but it would be encoded by each manufaturer with sub-encoding of some kind - otherwise every wireless PIR would work with each manufactureres panel on the same frequency, and they dont.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.